HolyTrainer 2 small vs. standard sheath...

[TheBottomBoy]

This is a difficult one.
My flaccid penis is exactly 10 cm (3.9 inches) measured form the top and 6 cm (2.35 inches) measured from the bottom in the way Thumper writes on his amazing blog.

So now I have this decision to make: From my measurements, the standard size tube would fit pretty much exactly, but Thumper suggests that a slightly smaller size provides a little bit of compression and is more comfortable to wear. In my case, the small tube of the HolyTrainer v2 would slightly compress my cock.

As this will be my first real chastity device, I would be glad if some of you more experienced members of the chastity community would provide an opinion on what you would do in my case, before I spend 170 dollars...

Best regards
BottomBoy

[slave d]

Generally speaking my experience is smaller is better but i'm just a little dickie (as MsM calls me).

d

[TheBottomBoy]

Thank you very much, slave_d

I'm also thinking that smaller is better but considerung the size of my cock and cage it would be quite a bit squished up - does that make a difference for long term comfort?

[slave d]

Sorry but i'm not big enough to be sure.

d

[ManagedMan]

I have both the HT2 regular and the short. I much prefer the short. I can fill either tube flaccid. But when I get aroused, the smaller tube helps keep things under control. The feeling of that compression is quite amazing. In the larger tube I don't feel it as much.

Is that measurement your average flaccid length from samples taken across a couple days? A man's penis changes quite a lot in size and length throughout the day. Find your average, not your max.

Either way, you can always use the stocking method to get yourself into the tube completely. You will be amazed at how much your flaccid penis can compress and fit into a tight space.

[newbie]

Here's my two cents:
I've also tried both the standard and small tube, and while I like the restrictive/compressive part of wearing the short tube I did notice that the base ring and integral lock "bump" would tend to slide down the shaft of my penis instead of staying put and restricting my shaft length. This would create a weird bulge in the front of my pants which would ruin the concealment that I was wearing something. I tried a smaller base ring (went from a 40 mm to a 36 mm) but that turned out to be way too small for me, even after I had worn the 40 mm ring for a long time and figured I could probably go smaller with no issues.

I ended up going back to the standard tube and it fits alot better. I pretty much touch the end all the time with the exception of some occasional shrinkage, and the base ring stays where it should up against my pelvic area, even with the 40 mm ring.